Weather 
NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!
If you or someone you know is having thoughts of suicide, please contact the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 1-800-273-TALK (8255).
WARNING: GRAPHIC CONTENT
A Florida man is behind bars awaiting trial after allegedly killing a young woman who traveled from the United Kingdom to pay him to carry out their plan for her to be “sexually abused, tortured, and murdered,” court records show.
Sonia Exelby of Portsmouth, England, was reported missing in October 2025 by her family when she failed to return home from a trip to the United States, records show.
Text communications to one of Exelby’s friends suggest she’d regretted her decision and wanted to back out of the deal she’d allegedly made with Hall to torture and kill her, records show.
FLORIDA MAN WHO ALLEGEDLY LURED WOMEN WITH DATING APP COULD HAVE MORE VICTIMS: AUTHORITIES
But it apparently was too late.
Days later, investigators found her body in a shallow grave in a wooded area in Ocala, Florida.
Now 54-year-old Dwain Hall of Ocala, Florida, faces charges of premeditated, first-degree murder and kidnapping. His trial is scheduled for Nov. 5 in Marion County, Florida.
Hatching a deadly plan
In 2023, Hall and Exelby met on a “fetish website” where they discussed “bondage, suicide, and her desire to have someone kill her,” according to court records.
Hall, a self-described sadist, allegedly started what he described as a process of “mentoring” Exelby, investigators who reviewed their messages said.
A Facebook page attributed to Hall shows a fascination with Anubis, said to be the Egyptian god of the underworld.
In the year leading up to her death, Exelby offered to “help Hall with money he owed to the IRS,” their online conversation showed, according to investigators.
They allegedly agreed that Exelby would pay him $4,000 cash to pay his debt in exchange for his help achieving “what she wanted,” court records show. And they allegedly came up with a “cover story,” to tell their families, and potentially law enforcement, records show.
After two years of online messaging, the young woman with a love of singing booked a flight from England to a rural area of North Florida to meet Hall, investigators said.
It wasn’t the first time she’d hatched a plan for her death, reports show.
Authorities in the United Kingdom thwarted a 2024 attempt by Exelby to travel to meet “online individuals who would be willing to kill her violently,” court records show. And she had “known mental health diagnoses,” investigators said.
This time, court records show, Exelby left evidence on her computer indicating that she was “again suicidal and traveling to the United States to be possibly sexually abused, tortured, and murdered by unknown individuals living in the United States.”
Exelby flew to Gainesville Regional Airport in Gainesville, Florida, on the evening of Oct. 10, 2025. She had a return flight scheduled for Oct. 13.
Investigators said Hall picked up Exelby in a vehicle and took her to an Airbnb 40 minutes south in Reddick, Florida. She’d reserved it in her name, court records show.
Before picking her up at the airport, Hall purchased gun cleaner, 50 feet of rope, Lume spray deodorant, and sturdy, nylon, parachute cord at a Gainesville Walmart.
After paying for the items, he went back for one more thing—a shovel.
Those alleged details were gathered by investigators with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, who reviewed Walmart receipts and surveillance video.
‘So scared’ and ‘So broken’
On Oct. 11, after spending one night with Hall, Exelby sent “long, and at times disjointed” messages to a friend through Discord, investigators said.
Exelby allegedly wrote that “last night was so bad,” and Hall had her “locked in” and had taken her phone because “he doesn’t trust me with it,” records show. She noted there was poor cellphone signal “in the middle of nowhere.”
She fretted about regret and a gruesome choice.
“I thought he’d do it quick and not give my mind time to stew,” she wrote. She said she knew it would be her last communication “if I don’t take his offer of shooting him,” she wrote.
In the messages, she said the person she was with “made her record three disclaimer videos and write a letter to her family because he thought it was ‘funny,’” investigation notes show.
“I’m so so scared I’m so broken and in so much pain all I can do is lay here,” Exelby wrote. “I’m sorry I don’t even know what I’m saying and I’m trying to be quick and my time’s up.”
Missing, then found
On Oct. 11, the same day Exelby messaged her friend, Hall’s bank account for his roadside assistance business charged Exelby’s debit card seven times within about 10 minutes.
After Exelby didn’t show up for her Oct. 13 flight home, she was reported missing.
Shortly after, charges to Exelby’s debit card paid to Hall’s business helped lead investigators to him.
On Oct. 17, law enforcement found Exelby’s body buried in a shallow grave in a wooded area of Marion County, court records show. Four stab wounds were found on the side of her body. The label for the shovel Hall bought at Walmart was found in the top layers of dirt, investigators said.
That same day, Hall was spotted by sheriff’s deputies and was pulled over while driving his black Jeep Cherokee on Interstate 75 in the Ocala area.
DATING-APP CHARMER ACCUSED OF MURDER AFTER HISTORY OF DOMESTIC ARRESTS INVOLVING WOMEN HE MET ONLINE
Before being taken into custody, investigators said Hall allegedly messaged a friend over Facebook about a package he was sending that contained “precious and valuable personal items.” “Will need this back in 6 months if this storm passes over with no lingering fallout,” Hall allegedly wrote in the messages reviewed by investigators. “Please for the love of shadows don’t lose this box.”
Investigators later recovered the package contents from Hall’s friend. They found a bracelet and a black, seven-inch, steel knife “designed for piercing and stabbing,” court records show.
The knife blade was engraved with the words: “Dorkworf pointy end goes in the other guy.” The friend told investigators that “Dorkworf” was “making fun of Hall’s use of the Darkwolf name while online.”
FOLLOW THE FOX TRUE CRIME TEAM ON X
DNA from blood samples recovered from the knife matched Exelby’s.
Initially, Hall denied to investigators that he knew Exelby, court records show.
But eventually, he described how he’d taken a video of her, but that she “was not behaving right so he deleted it.”
Frightening video
Investigators later recovered the video that Hall recorded the same day Exelby messaged her friend. It had been deleted three seconds later, records show.
The 4-minute-and-16-second video shows a bruised, “disheveled” Exelby “sitting on a piece of furniture” in the Airbnb. Hall allegedly can be heard asking her questions and directing her answers, reports show. In the video, Exelby “rarely looks up towards the camera where Hall would be positioned, becomes visibly upset with tears in her eyes, exhales deeply, swallows hard, and is very hesitant to answer Hall’s questions,” investigators wrote in an affidavit.
SIGN UP TO GET THE LATEST TRUE CRIME NEWS
When Hall asks Exelby to tell him “why she is here,” she responds, “Because I’m an awful person.”
When pressed by Hall, Exelby explains, “I’ve crushed everyone who ever loves me.”
LIKE WHAT YOU’RE READING? CLICK HERE FOR MORE
When pressed further to say how she “would want to die,” Exelby hesitates, then says she wants to be stabbed.
Under his questioning, she reveals that she’s been beaten over the past days. When asked if she was coerced, she silently shakes her head.
SEND US A TIP
Hall demands, “This is how you wanted to die, right? You wanted to be beaten and made to suffer because you’re such a piece of s—.”
She nods.
GOT A TIP?
Hall orders: “Say it.”
“I needed to be beaten and suffer cause I’m such a piece of s—,” Exelby says.
LISTEN TO THE NEW ‘CRIME & JUSTICE WITH DONNA ROTUNNO’ PODCAST
“Good, good,” Hall replies. He asks her if she is happy and getting what she wants.
She nods her head.
GET BREAKING NEWS BY EMAIL
Hall later told investigators Exelby didn’t “do what she was supposed to do,” court records show.
CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP
She didn’t bring him cash and he was upset, he allegedly told them.
Instead, she gave him her debit card to charge. But he was only able to get $1,200 from it after it was declined several times. Hall is being held in the Marion County Jail on six felony charges and could face the death penalty. His legal representative did not respond to a request for comment from Fox News Digital.
