Rents are climbing. Groceries aren’t getting any cheaper. And now, apparently, a smoothie costs roughly what you’d pay for a cocktail at a swanky Manhattan bar.
Yet that didn’t stop New Yorkers from setting their alarms before sunrise on Thursday this week, for a taste of LA’s cult (and eye-wateringly overpriced) wellness scene.
Erewhon, the City of Angels grocery chain synonymous with celebrity-endorsed smoothies and A-list devotees, opened its first permanent public outlet on November 20, inside Kith Women’s flagship store at 644 Broadway in NoHo.
But it wasn’t just any store. Erewhon’s pretentiously named Tonic Bar was designed to look more like somewhere you’d sip a martini than grab a smoothie.
It’s where instead of booze, glorified fruit blends come packed with superfoods, trendy supplements and enough wellness buzzwords to make your head spin.
Judging by the crowds, the prices were hardly scaring anyone off. Customers were happily shelling out $13 for lattes — which some might compare to sad, watered-down hot chocolate — and $21 for smoothies (all before tax) that one could call overly sweet and artificial-tasting.
And with more than 29 possible $1 add-ins — from ghee and spirulina to an assortment of milks and syrups — those already pricey drinks from the extensive menu could easily balloon to $30 or more.
Wellness devotees, curious first-timers and Erewhon superfans started lining up as early as 6:30 a.m., snagging black wristbands for priority entry and first dibs on the latest status-symbol breakfast.
Because nothing says fiscal responsibility quite like it.
Just ask Brittney Ava, 25, a self-proclaimed “Erewhon superfan” from Bed-Stuy, who was among the first four people in line.
With an Erewhon tote slung over her shoulder and a Rhode phone case in hand (Hailey Bieber’s brand, naturally), complete with the matching lip treatment, Ava looked every bit the LA-bound wellness devotee.
“Erewhon is modern luxe without having to spend too much money,” she told The Post, arguing that customers are paying for “high-quality, organic ingredients.”
Originally from Minneapolis, she moved to NYC in 2020 and plans to relocate to West Hollywood next year — making her $21 “Erewhon State of Mind” smoothie, a blend of organic cold-pressed apple juice, warming winter spices and goji berries, something of a preview of her next chapter.
Ava, a regular at the chain’s LA outposts, said Erewhon’s Kendall Jenner $23 Peaches & Cream smoothie changed her life.
Two years later, she’s “still not over it”.
She also believes the allure lies in the exclusivity — the thrill of getting a smoothie that’s not available on every corner.
“People know that they can only get this here, and that the smoothie is rare,” she said. “It’s that feeling of, ‘I can’t get this drink just anywhere.’”
Fiorella Rayme, 30, a Gramercy resident who works in marketing, was also among the enthusiastic arrivals.
A longtime fan who visits Erewhon whenever she’s in Los Angeles, Rayme first tried one of its smoothies in 2023 — an experience she still remembers fondly.
“I had my first Erewhon smoothie when I visited LA in 2023, and it was honestly life-changing,” she said.
After hearing about the New York opening, she immediately made plans to return the next morning with a friend, arriving at 8 a.m. and waiting about an hour to get inside.
This time, she ordered the $20 Cloud smoothie and an $11 iced matcha latte — which she waited 30 mins for. She believes New Yorkers “could use more healthy options here” — although some of Erewhon’s superfood-packed smoothies can top 600 calories per 20-ounce serving.
She hopes the Tonic Bar is just the beginning of the brand’s expansion in the city.
Inside, guests were even offered complimentary bouquets from PlantShed while waiting for their orders, because nothing says wellness quite like a pricey smoothie and a fresh floral arrangement.
And while some customers were thrilled to finally get their Erewhon fix without having to book a flight to the West Coast, others weren’t exactly convinced that Gotham was in dire need of its arrival.
“It’s not like the city doesn’t already have great spots,” said Fredy Tista, a Manhattan-based content creator who was trying the brand for the first time.
Tista, who ordered the famous Strawberry Glaze smoothie associated with Hailey Bieber ($21), said he was more interested in the organic ingredients — like “fresh coconut cream” than the A-lister connection.
For other customers, the opening was a chance to finally see what all the fuss was about.
Monica Kwan, 23, a fashion business student at FIT who lives near Hudson Yards, arrived at 8:07 a.m. and waited about 50 minutes before getting inside. She ordered the Strawberry Glaze smoothie ($21) for a friend and the Malibu Mango ($21) for herself, having been drawn in by the social media buzz.
But Kwan, who is originally from South Korea, said she wasn’t about to spend her morning waiting in every trendy line that came along.
“I’m selective. I’m not usually one to wait in long lines for pop-ups because I don’t always think the experience is worth the time,” she said.
“Today, however, I didn’t have any classes.”
After trying both drinks, she preferred the Malibu Mango, which she found less sweet than some of the others.
As for this reporter, I tried the $16 Almond Butter Blast, a blend of almond milk, banana, peanut butter, cacao and plant protein.
But it couldn’t hold a candle to my go-to $7 smoothie from Urban Valley Natural Market in Bushwick, Brooklyn — a similarly sized plastic-cup concoction of banana, oats, peanut butter, cinnamon and almond milk that costs $9 less.
And that’s perhaps the biggest question facing Erewhon as it plants its flag in New York: Can a brand built on LA exclusivity win over a city that already does this — and sometimes at a quarter of the price?
For now, the curious crowds are showing up.
Whether they’ll keep coming back once the novelty — and the free flowers — wear off remains to be seen.
